The Jeep Wrangler is iconic for its removable tops, allowing owners to customize their ride for any weather condition or adventure. Two popular top choices are the hard top and soft top, both offering unique benefits and drawbacks. This guide will compare hardtop vs soft top Jeep Wranglers to help you decide which is better for your needs.
Jeep Wrangler Hard Top Benefits
Maximum Durability and Security
Hard tops are constructed from heavy-duty materials like fiberglass or impact-resistant polycarbonate plastic. This makes them extremely durable and able to withstand more extreme off-roading conditions without damage. Hard tops also provide superior security compared to soft tops, as they cannot be easily cut or torn into.
Better Insulation and Sound Dampening
The rigid construction of a hard top allows for excellent temperature and noise control inside the cabin. Hard tops insulate against cold winter temps far better than soft versions, keeping you cozy inside. They also dampen exterior noise from wind, other vehicles, and off-roading significantly more. This creates a noticeably quieter ride.
Allow Roof Racks and Storage Systems
Due to their reinforced structure, hard tops permit installing roof racks for hauling bikes, kayaks, luggage and more up top. Soft tops cannot safely bear heavy roof loads. Hard tops also allow attaching roof-top tents for camping and provide the option to bolt on cargo storage systems.
Easier to Keep Clean Long-Term
Although soft tops are initially easier to clean, hard tops stay cleaner looking over time. Their smooth, rigid exterior prevents dust and debris accumulation that can make canvas soft tops look aged and dingy. Hard tops only need occasional washing to keep their sleek factory look.
Related: Differences Across Wrangler Models
Jeep Wrangler Hard Top Drawbacks
Difficult Removal and Installation
Detaching and reattaching a hard top requires heavy lifting and is best done with two people. The awkward maneuvering of bulky fiberglass or plastic panels makes it challenging compared to folding down a soft top. You’ll also need a place to securely store the hard top when removed.
Expensive to Replace if Damaged
Although hard tops are extremely durable, if cracked or heavily impacted, replacement costs are quite high, often $1000 or more. The expensive molded materials and production methods make hard top panels pricey to swap out if irreparably damaged.
Lack of Open-Air Experience
With a hard top always in place, you miss out on the thrill of open-air off-roading unless you remove side doors and windows. Even with these off, hard tops still block some sunshine and openness soft tops provide.
Soft Top Benefits
Breezy Open-Air Feeling
Soft tops fold down easily to allow a fun, breezy open-air experience. They give you quick access to sunshine and views above while driving or parked. You can also easily remove side windows and doors when used with a soft top to customize airiness.
Convenient Storage and Removal
Soft tops fold into a compact size for hassle-free removal, storage and reinstallation. There are no bulky panels to dismount and find space for. The lightweight canvas material makes removal a simple one-person operation.
Adaptability in Changing Weather
With soft tops, you can quickly adjust to shifting weather conditions. A sudden rainstorm or cooling temperature is no problem to react to when you can swiftly re-erect your soft top as needed. Unexpected weather changes become more manageable.
Lower Replacement Cost
Although soft tops must be replaced more frequently than hard tops, they cost significantly less. Quality aftermarket replacements often run $400-$600 installed. OEM versions cost more but still less than replacing a single hard top panel.
Soft Top Drawbacks
Vulnerable to Damage
Soft tops are easily slashed, snagged and torn if branches or rocks hit them while off-roading. They can also be cut open by thieves much more quickly than hard tops. Staying vigilant about damage and security is important with soft tops.
Offer Less Insulation and Noise Dampening
Canvas soft tops transmit more external noise and temperature compared to hardtops. This can make driving uncomfortable in very hot or cold weather. Soft tops also flap loudly at higher speeds, diminishing noise reduction.
Cannot Support Roof Storage Systems
The flexible canvas construction of soft tops precludes attaching roof racks, cargo pods or roof-top tents. Only lightweight gear like sleeping bags can be carried up top safely. Hard tops are required for heavier roof storage setups.
Tougher Long-Term Maintenance
Over years of use, soft tops show more wear like small tears, dust buildup, water stains and mildew. Keeping soft tops looking good long-term takes more frequent cleaning, conditioning and repair.
Factors Impacting Your Wrangler Choice
Where You Live and Drive
Frequent fair weather drivers in warmer climates will likely appreciate a soft top’s breezy openness more. Those in cooler northern regions who want maximum insulation and noise reduction may prefer a hard top. Also consider if you’ll often park in insecure areas where soft top slashing is a risk.
Your Budget For Upgrades and Repairs
Hard tops demand a bigger upfront investment, but soft tops require more continual maintenance spending. Consider both initial cost and longer-term repair/replacement costs for your budget.
How You Use Your Wrangler
If you install roof racks, cargo pods, or rooftop tents, a hardtop is required. For casual sunny weekend cruising, a soft top may satisfy. Assess your lifestyle and how you plan to use your Jeep.
Your Mechanical Skill Level
Soft tops are easier for DIY removal and installation. Hard tops require more skill and potential modifications like adding header latches. Factor your mechanical confidence and willingness to learn new skills.
Aftermarket Options
Many excellent aftermarket soft and hard tops are available to factory hard tops. This increases style and customization choices. Aftermarket hard tops can also cost significantly less than OEM versions.
Helpful Hints for Jeep Wrangler Soft Top Owners
- Use padding and brackets on roll bars to prevent fabric snagging.
- Park out of direct sunlight when possible to minimize fading.
- Rinse off dust and dirt weekly to prevent buildup.
- Use protectants like 303 Aerospace to repel water and condition the fabric.
- Inspect for tears after off-roading and repair quickly.
- Consider a lockable soft top storage bag to deter slashing.
- Use side mirrors to check for flapping noise and adjust as needed.
Tips for Jeep Wrangler Hard Top Owners
- Add interior insulation for improved temperature and noise control.
- Install header latches to simplify removal and improve security.
- Use jacks or pulley systems to lift hardtop panels safely.
- Apply protective film to prevent scratches during removal and installation.
- Properly seal all edges and hardware to prevent leaks.
- Consider an aftermarket hard top for greater style selection and value.
Conclusion
When choosing between a Jeep Wrangler’s hard top vs soft top, reflect on your climate, budget, usage needs and skills. There are excellent benefits to both options if matched properly to your situation. Maintain your top well and you can enjoy miles of epic open-air adventure in the iconic Jeep Wrangler.
References:
https://www.cjponyparts.com/resources/wrangler-hardtop-vs-soft-top
https://www.jlwranglerforums.com/forum/threads/hard-top-vs-soft-top-pros-and-cons.93120/
